Pudding Club

What's included in the pudding club box?

Each Pudding of the Month box includes three fresh Limited-Time Pudding cups, three fresh Classic Banana Pudding cups, and a special sweet surprise that changes monthly!

If I order a subscription, will it automatically renew?

At the end of the Pudding of the Month subscription, you’ll have the option of subscribing again to any of our plans. If you do not choose to purchase a new subscription, it will simply end and you will not be charged again or receive further monthly

Can I send someone a subscription as a gift?

Yes! The Pudding of the Month club makes a delicious gift! Please select the gift option when adding the subscription to your cart, where you’ll be able to input a gift message and the recipient’s information. Be sure to enter the recipient’s delive

Pudding Club - Is shipping really free?

Yes! The subscription price you see here is what you will pay, excluding any location-specific sales taxes.

Can I change the shipping address on my order?

Yes, we can update the original shipping address. Please contact [email protected] with the updated address and order number with a minimum of 72 hours in advance of the next scheduled delivery date and our team will update the shipping addre

Can I substitute a flavor?

We carefully select our Pudding Club flavors of the month according to seasonal trends and special events. To preserve this special experience, we do not offer substitutions or swaps.

Can I change my delivery date or hold my subscription?

While we do not offer subscription pausing, you may select an alternative delivery date from the options offered before the 3rd of the month of your delivery. You can do so for each month’s shipment within your account portal. Access your portal by c

How do I cancel my subscription?

Subscriptions placed on magnoliabakery.com cannot be canceled or refunded. However, if you want to stop deliveries, please contact our customer service team and we will address each issue on a case-by-case basis.

When can I expect my first order to arrive?

By default, your order will arrive on the second Thursday of each month your subscription is active. You may change between available delivery dates within your account portal before the third of each month.

Do I pay for a Pudding of the Month subscription upfront or over time?

The subscription is prepaid in-full upfront. You will not be charged monthly and will only be charged again if you purchase a new subscription, as it does not renew automatically.

Do I get to know the flavors ahead of time?

No, our monthly flavors will be announced at the beginning of every month to coincide with their availability in-store. Don’t worry, the surprise will be worth it! Past monthly flavors include Pumpkin Spice, Carrot Cake, Chocolate Covered Strawberry,

How is the dessert shipped, and where is it shipped to?

Every month, your dessert will be sent to the shipping address you enter at checkout via FedEx overnight delivery to ensure freshness. If you are subscribing for yourself, enter your address as the shipping address. If you are subscribing as a gift t

Does each pudding contain the same allergens?

All of our pudding is produced in a facility that processes eggs, wheat, dairy, tree nuts, pine nuts, and other major allergens.

Can I purchase Route insurance coverage for a subscription order to protect against loss or damage?

Yes, you can purchase Route insurance coverage at checkout. While we strive to ensure your products always arrive fresh and on time, we realize that this may not always be the case. Route insurance coverage ensures that you are compensated in case of

What if I have more questions?

If you have additional questions, you can email us and we will do our best to assist you. You’re also welcome to visit any of our bakery locations during their business hours to check out our wonderful selection in person. You can view our Terms of S